What is the definition of redemtion that is substantially disproportionate?

Category : Stock Options | ISO | NSO
Posted On : 10th Mar 2025

The term'substantially disproportionate redemption' refers to a situation in corporate taxation where a corporation buys a shareholder's stock. The transaction is able to receive favorable tax treatment as a sale or exchange instead of a dividend. To achieve this, the U.S. tax law (Section 302 of the Internal Revenue Code) necessitates meting certain criteria.

  • Upon redemption, the shareholder is required to have less than 50% of the total combined voting power of all classes of stock eligible to vote.
  • After the redemption, the shareholder's percentage of voting stock must decrease by more than 80% from before the redemption.
  • Shares that are indirectly owned through family members or entities under constructive ownership rules can also be included in the ownership test.
  • If these conditions are satisfied, the redemption is treated as a sale or exchange, meaning the shareholder is taxed only on the gain rather than the entire amount being taxed as a dividend.

To comprehend the rules for substantially disproportional redemption, I will utilize a case study.

  • An individual shareholder owns 275 share of an "O-Corporaion".
  • O-Corporaion has 1000 shares of common stockoutstanding and redeems 200 shares of common stock from its shareholders.
  • The least number of "Individual's" shares that will need to be redeemed in order for the redemption to be substantially disproportionate  to Carol is determined are: "Individual" owns 27.5% [(275/1,000) x 100 of "O-Corporation's
     before the redemption (275 shares/1000 shares).
  • Individual must reduce interest below to 22% for the redemption to be ubstantially disproportionate (80% x 27.5%).
  • Individual needs to own less than 176 shares after the redemption 22% x (1,000 shares - 200 Shares).
  • Thus, more than 99% shares  (275 Shares -176 Shares) needs to be redeemed to reduce "Individual's" interest below 22%.

Conclusion: Accordingly ("Individual's) needs to have a minimum of 100 shares redeemed for the redemption to be substantially disproporionate.

 

Your order has been processed successfully, congratulations! To check the status of your order, log in on the front page.
Our customer service number is 1+(516).822.3100.